Controversial topics can spark lively debates and discussions in the classroom, but they can also pose challenges for both educators and students. How can we create a safe and respectful learning environment where students can express their opinions and learn from different perspectives?
In this EDU Blog, we will explore some effective ways to teach controversial topics in a way that promotes critical thinking, dialogue and diversity.
What are the Controversial Topics?
The first step in teaching controversial topics is to identify what they are. This may seem obvious, but it can be challenging to determine what topics are controversial and to what extent.
Some topics may be more controversial than others depending on the context, the audience, the culture, the period, and so on. For example, a controversial topic in one country may not be in another, or a controversial topic in the past may not be now.
To evaluate the suitability of a topic for an argumentative essay, you can ask yourself the following questions:
Is there more than one reasonable point of view on this topic?
How does this topic relate to values, beliefs, or emotions people care deeply about?
What are the potential impacts of this topic on people’s lives or well-being?
How often does this topic spark heated debates or disagreements in the media or society?
What are the social justice or human rights implications of this topic?
If you answer yes to any of these questions, you will likely deal with a controversial topic. However, you should also be aware that some topics may not seem controversial to you but may be to your students or vice versa. Therefore, it is essential to consult with your students and colleagues before choosing a controversial topic to teach.
How to Teach Controversial Topics in Diverse Classrooms
1. Know Your Students and Yourself
Before teaching any controversial topic, it is important to know your students’ prior knowledge, attitudes, values, and experiences related to the topic. For example, using surveys, polls, discussions, or other activities to assess your students‘ readiness and interest. Be aware of the diversity of your students’ cultural, linguistic, religious, socioeconomic, and other backgrounds, and how they may influence their perspectives on the topic.
Simultaneously, you should also reflect on your own opinions, biases, assumptions, and emotions about the topic, and how they may affect your teaching. Be prepared to explain why you are teaching the topic and how it relates to your subject area and students’ learning.
2. Establish Clear Goals and Expectations
A controversial topic needs a clear purpose and objective. You should communicate these to your students at the start of the lesson or unit. Additionally, you should establish clear expectations for the discussion process. These include how the students should behave, participate, engage, and evaluate.
Moreover, you should show how the topic relates to the course content and learning outcomes. And how it builds on the students’ prior knowledge and experiences. For example, you can use tools like rubrics, checklists, or contracts. These make the expectations and goals for the discussion explicit.
3. Provide Multiple Perspectives and Sources
Teaching controversial topics can help students learn about different views and perspectives. These views and perspectives can make them question their own beliefs and opinions. To do this, you should use different types of sources and materials that show diverse voices and perspectives on the topic. For example, you can use texts, videos, podcasts, guest speakers, etc.
You should also ask students to do their own research and find more sources that agree or disagree with their own views. Moreover, you should teach students how to check the quality and trustworthiness of the sources they use. A good way to do this is to use graphic organizers, charts, or tables. They can help students compare and contrast different sources and perspectives.
4. Create a Safe and Respectful Environment
Teaching controversial topics can elicit strong emotions and reactions from students. As a result, this can lead to heated debates or arguments. To avoid this, you should create a safe and respectful environment for teaching controversial topics.
In this environment, students should feel comfortable expressing their opinions and listening to others. They should not fear judgment or ridicule. Here are some strategies you can use to create a safe and respectful environment:
Model respectful behavior and language yourself.
Intervene necessary to prevent or address any inappropriate or disrespectful comments or actions.
Acknowledge and validate students’ feelings and experiences.
Help them cope with any discomfort or distress they may feel.
- Use ground rules, signals, or debriefs to create a safe and respectful environment.attis, pulvinar dapibus leo.
5. Facilitate Meaningful Dialogue and Reflection
To help students learn from controversial topics, you need to do more than just give them information or facts. You need to engage them in dialogs and reflections that help them deepen their understanding and critical thinking skills. To do this, you need to ask questions that are open-ended, invite different viewpoints, challenge assumptions, clear up misunderstandings, summarize main ideas, etc.
In addition, you need to give students chances to think about their own learning process and outcomes. For example, you can ask them to write journals, create portfolios, fill out surveys, etc.
You also need to give feedback and assessment that focus on how well students participate and reason rather than on whether they agree or disagree with a certain position. For example, you can use exit slips, peer feedback forms, or self-assessment tools to help students have meaningful dialogs and reflections.
In General
Teaching controversial topics is difficult because they can cause student disagreements or conflicts. However, these topics can also be very rewarding for both educators and students. They can help us develop critical thinking, respectful dialogue, and cultural awareness skills in diverse classrooms.
Do you want to learn more about teaching and education? Don’t miss our EDU Blogs! We have many valuable tips and tricks and the latest news in education. Subscribe for EDU Passport today!
