The Great Homework Debates

The great homework debates between parents and educators have been pretty intense over the years.

Homework has remained a constant presence in students’ lives for so long that the idea of not having to do it can be quite appealing.

Some argue homework helps parents engage with, and support their children with subjects they’re studying.

While some assert that developing time management skills and meeting deadlines is crucial to a student’s growth.

But they advise against strict deadlines and short time frames for homework, warning of negative impacts on learning outcomes.

The ongoing debate over whether schools should eliminate homework requires considering both advantages and disadvantages.

What Are the Homework Debates?

The ongoing discussions surrounding homework revolve around its potential to foster good study habits or act as a hindrance to academic progress.

Parents, students, and educators, hold contrasting views on whether homework has a positive or negative impact.

Typically, homework comprises assignments given by educators to be completed outside of regular school hours.

Homework reflects teachers’ grasp of the curriculum and their insight into their students’ abilities and requirements.

However, the extent of homework and its role in our educational lives depend on several factors.

Over the 20th century, public discourse regarding homework has followed a cyclical pattern. What’s needed now is a middle ground that acknowledges both the benefits and drawbacks of homework.

Homework is complex because it relies on individual differences among students and their home environments. 

Since students take homework to different household environments (financial, social, etc.), it’s challenging for educators to facilitate and grade everyone fairly.

Some researchers argue that the crucial issue isn’t whether students should have homework but the nature and quantity of homework assigned.

Effective homework should be tailored to students’ specific needs. For example, certain middle school teachers have achieved success with online math assignments that match each student’s level of understanding.

However, when middle school students were given more than an hour and a half of homework, their performance in math and science tests suffered.

Recent research even suggests that the time spent on homework doesn’t consistently predict academic achievement and, in some cases, may even have a negative impact.

As a general guideline, schools typically encourage students to spend a maximum of 10 minutes on daily homework assignments.

If educators assign homework, they should plan it carefully.

Is Homework Good or Bad?

Educators assign homework to students on a daily basis, aiming to impart new knowledge and reinforce what has been taught in class.

This necessitates dedication and practice on the part of the students.

Is homework beneficial or detrimental?

At times, it appears to have pros as it can enhance one’s exam performance and serve as a means to prepare for tests.

Nevertheless, its advantages aren’t always clear-cut and homework can occasionally have a negative impact.

Why is Homework Good?

Homework holds a significant role in a student’s educational journey, offering numerous advantages that contribute to their education.

The following reasons are why homework assignments beyond class hours benefit students:

Reinforcement of Learning 

Homework presents a valuable opportunity for students to practice and apply what they’ve learned in the classroom.

It plays a pivotal role in helping them understand various concepts, ultimately enhancing their retention of the subject matter.

Cultivation of Independent Learning Skills 

Completing homework assignments nurtures self-reliance and responsibility in students.

It fosters crucial life skills like time management, organization, and discipline, valuable beyond academics.

Preparation for Tests and Exams 

Homework serves as a strategic tool for exam readiness.

It enables students to apply knowledge, identify areas needing support, and cultivate useful study habits for assessments.

Fostering Parental Involvement 

Homework assignments often involve parents and guardians, facilitating a strong connection between home and school.

This involvement allows parents to actively support their child’s education, keep tabs on their progress, and offer guidance when needed.

Enhancement of Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving 

Many homework tasks necessitate critical thinking, problem-solving, and information analysis.

These cognitive abilities are not only crucial for academic success but also for real-world challenges, equipping students with multiple helpful skills.

Why is Homework Unnecessary?

Advocates for homework reform push for enhancing in-class learning and focusing on deeper subject comprehension.

The following reasons are why some educators and experts question the need for homework:

Unclear Benefits 

Despite the time and effort students dedicate to homework, research often struggles to establish a concrete connection between homework and improved academic performance.

Many students complete assignments simply to meet requirements rather than gaining a deeper understanding of the material.

Impact on Family Time 

Homework can occupy most of a student’s after-school hours, leaving limited time for family interactions, relaxation, and participation in extracurricular activities.

This can lead to increased stress and a reduced overall quality of life for students.


Homework may have a disproportionate impact on students from disadvantaged backgrounds.

They might lack access to essential resources like a quiet study space, the internet, or parental assistance.

This forces educational disparities.

Grade-Centric Focus 

Homework often places a strong emphasis on grades rather than the learning process itself.

Students may resort to shortcuts like plagiarism or excessive parental assistance to achieve higher grades, which defeats the educational purpose.

Reduced Engagement 

Many students find homework uninteresting and monotonous.

This can lead to lesser engagement with the learning process, fostering a negative attitude towards education.

Final Thoughts

The concept of homework has evolved, with some regarding it as a valuable tool for academic development, while others argue that it may prevent progress. As the debate concerning homework’s role in education continues, it’s essential to consider its pros and cons.

Sign up for the full EDU Passport experience here. 

Follow us

Top Articles

Share this article

The world is waiting to hear your voice!

EDU Blog is the perfect place to share your insights and experiences with the world. Apply to become a guest author today!

Related Articles